Using technologies, such as Geogebra and SketchPad, to show thousands
of cases of the problem/situation, would be enough dynamic geometry proving for
Secondary Students. This is because students would think they’ve seen all cases
and this is the proof. However, as users of the program, we are never sure of
whether we’ve touched on all cases for the problem/situation. Therefore,
geometry proving is not a sufficient proving method, but it can initiate a confidence
and direction in students to prove the problems.
Deductive proof is a real proof that shows the proving for
all cases. Now, this type of proofs may be tedious for many problems, and high
school students may not have the patience or interest to work on it or read
through it. But since the math topics we touch on in high school curriculum are
simple and are not very deep into topics, the proofs for most topics/formula
are simple and easy to understand. Therefore, to initiate the interests and
inquiry thinking of math in our students, teachers should always touch on the
proofs in each topic. I believe this will also help students to learn better throughout
the chapters.
I think some great chapters to get students to start
thinking about proving are the geometry units. By looking at the given graphs,
they will come up with conjectures about the solution. However, we should never
believe our conjectures without proving. Therefore, it would be nice to have
students sharing their ideas in peers and try to figure out a proving. Doing
this might lead them to an answer. Some students might be better at spatial
thinking, and if they share their ideas within their groups, they will get feedbacks
from their peers as well. Then everyone in the group will know how to prove the
answer, and sometimes, other people in the group might have different ways of
solving the same problem. This gives everyone a chance to be open minded and
see which solution is quicker to the answer and get a sense of what to do first
next time when they see a similar problem similar to this one. When students
try to write down their solutions in mathematical languages, this would be
similar to having a good deductive proof for the problem. Because, this proof
can be shown to a sceptic, and he/she will understand the solution of the
problem without students’ presence. (In most cases, sceptics would be the teachers.)
In conclusion, when I teach geometry proving chapters, it
would be a good idea to have students to work in peers, to share their ideas
and opinions, and thus to improve their proving and solving skills. By thinking
about John Mason’s three levels of proofs, I get a better sense of how to
develop students’ problem solving and proving skills in the class.
Lovely work here, Annie!
ReplyDelete