Thursday, December 29, 2016

Peer Teaching Reflect

Our peer teaching was on the topic of Laws of Logarithm.
We review the previous knowledge together as a group and separate the students into three groups so that we each teach a section of the lesson, and the students rotate in between different student teacher for the complete lesson.
I was teaching the product law of logarithm. In the beginning of my lesson, just as one of the peer comments mentioned, my voice was a bit low because of all the noises in the classroom. However, after half a minute or so, I gradually found my voice that my student-classmates can hear. I see this as a valuable experience because in an actual classroom, high school students can be noisy sometimes, I should be able to find a right voice to manage the class.

Overall, I think we did a good job on the lesson. The split and the smaller class worked well since each of us was only teaching two people. This way we had better access to teach and help our student-classmates with their questions. However, the down side of this split is that each of our team member were teaching at difference paces, therefore, when it comes to the rotation, sometimes other members need to wrap up quickly. 

Sunday, December 11, 2016

Proof

Using technologies, such as Geogebra and SketchPad, to show thousands of cases of the problem/situation, would be enough dynamic geometry proving for Secondary Students. This is because students would think they’ve seen all cases and this is the proof. However, as users of the program, we are never sure of whether we’ve touched on all cases for the problem/situation. Therefore, geometry proving is not a sufficient proving method, but it can initiate a confidence and direction in students to prove the problems.

Deductive proof is a real proof that shows the proving for all cases. Now, this type of proofs may be tedious for many problems, and high school students may not have the patience or interest to work on it or read through it. But since the math topics we touch on in high school curriculum are simple and are not very deep into topics, the proofs for most topics/formula are simple and easy to understand. Therefore, to initiate the interests and inquiry thinking of math in our students, teachers should always touch on the proofs in each topic. I believe this will also help students to learn better throughout the chapters.

I think some great chapters to get students to start thinking about proving are the geometry units. By looking at the given graphs, they will come up with conjectures about the solution. However, we should never believe our conjectures without proving. Therefore, it would be nice to have students sharing their ideas in peers and try to figure out a proving. Doing this might lead them to an answer. Some students might be better at spatial thinking, and if they share their ideas within their groups, they will get feedbacks from their peers as well. Then everyone in the group will know how to prove the answer, and sometimes, other people in the group might have different ways of solving the same problem. This gives everyone a chance to be open minded and see which solution is quicker to the answer and get a sense of what to do first next time when they see a similar problem similar to this one. When students try to write down their solutions in mathematical languages, this would be similar to having a good deductive proof for the problem. Because, this proof can be shown to a sceptic, and he/she will understand the solution of the problem without students’ presence. (In most cases, sceptics would be the teachers.)


In conclusion, when I teach geometry proving chapters, it would be a good idea to have students to work in peers, to share their ideas and opinions, and thus to improve their proving and solving skills. By thinking about John Mason’s three levels of proofs, I get a better sense of how to develop students’ problem solving and proving skills in the class.

Sunday, December 4, 2016

MOA Math Fair

During the math fair, the elementary students were able to make bonds between their math problems and corners in the anthropology museum. Students said that they were brought to the museum three weeks ago to observe and relate their problems to aboriginal people’s stories or items.  

It was surprised to see that many students were very creative at presenting their problems. They make equipment and tools that will help themselves and guests to understand and solve the problem better. Many visual tools they prepared were neat and colorful which attracted guests’ attentions. The visual tools gave guests a chance to solve the problem without using paper and pencil, and it was fun to play with the tools. This gave me an idea that math should not be always on the textbook and paper. It would be great if teacher could provide students more opportunities to do hands-on activities during class times. This would bring up the atmosphere in the classroom, and so are students’ interests in the topics.


I have tried a few problems in the math fair. One of them is about filling in different color totem pole on to a 4*4 grid so that no two same colors appear on the same row, column or diagonal line. I was using logic similar to what I do in Sudoku to solve the problem. However, what are some related topics on the problem? Most students were able to solve or come up with more than one answers on their problem. Some could even find out some patterns in their solutions. However, they didn’t seem to realize that their problems have to do with some great mathematician’s works as well. It would be interesting if students could try to relate their problems with some mathematicians’ works. For instance, the fill-in-totems-on-grid problem might has to do with Euler’s Square. Some topic might lead to greater concepts, however, just by mentioning the theorems or referring back to a mathematician that has to do with the problem would show improvements in students researching skills. To help in building this skill, teachers that lead the fair, can prepare a list of names of mathematicians or theorems that have to do with the problems. This way, students have a resource and a direction to work on the problems. Students will research and decide on which mathematician or theorem is related to their problems. By relating the problems to the historical and mathematical references, students will feel greater accomplishment and this can help in building their self-efficacy in learning math.

Wednesday, November 30, 2016

Math Fair

Before I read the article, I thought holding a math fair is impossible because I have no idea how the process runs. With the introduction of the process of the math fair in the article, I first feel more ease about holding a math fair.  The procedures introduced in the article are clear and make sense.
I really like the idea of having a rehearsal before the math fair. The rehearsal will give students a chance to communicate and improve their explaining skills. It will help them to realize whether their ways of explaining the problem is easy for other people to understand or not. By observing the others and self-reflection, students will be doing better during the math fair.

The article provides a large resources of puzzles for teachers to pick from. This in which make the fair possible to hold because a good source of puzzles is the essence of the fair; and the resource would save me a big chunk of time if I were to create the problems myself. Most puzzles in the article are interesting, I feel students will like them. However, some questions contain large numbers or big vocabularies, which might not be suitable for the students in lower grades to understand. Part of the goal for the math fair is for students to engage in solving the problems instead of trying to understand the problems. Therefore, rephrasing the problems before presenting the list of problems to students is required.

Moreover, what more important than rephrasing the problem is how to pick the right problems for the students. I think it is always good to take a glance at the curriculum of the grade that will be doing the math fair before searching for the problems. This way, when I look at the problems, I can see whether the big idea behind the problem matches the curriculum or not.

I feel is it possible to do the math fair on  my Grade 10 classes during my long practicum because I will be teaching them for two month. Therefore, it is more plausible for me to squeeze the math fair into my teaching schedule. Since it is only Grade 10 students, I will need to do a good job on rephrasing the problems for them to understand the problems. Since we will be doing factoring in March, I will find some questions that are related to factorings. Maybe some questions with parabola-related figures(bridge..etc.) presented in the questions. This will help students to realize what they are solving for and why they are doing the factorings. I feel we will all enjoy the math fair If it is to be hold during my long practicum.

Monday, November 28, 2016

MathThatMatters Reflect

After reading the article, I’ve changed my idea about mathematics being neutral. Math is not neutral, and it can be connected with social/environmental justice. I agree with the author’s idea of bringing social justice into the classrooms. In other words, teachers should implement problem posing education into the classroom and relate the topics with useful real life situation, instead of keep using "banking education". Instead of depositing the knowledge to the students, creating a scaffolding topic, and letting students to explore the concept and to come up with their own problems for the topic, can be a better way for students to learn. This way, students will understand why they want to know answer, because they came up with the problems. Students will also recognize the power of math as an essential analytic tool to understand the potential changes in the world, rather than regard math as a set of disjointed rules to be memorized.

There are many topics in math that we can connect with social justice justice. For instance, when doing discount percentage and rates in Grade 8 and 9 math classes, we can implement an interesting activity. Students will be asked to print off copies of bills and coins from their heritage countries and bring one or two items to pretend to sell in the class. They will also make a discount sign that they've seen the most from their heritage countries. We will create a mini-market in class so that students will experience culture differences and understand the currency difference, and item value differences in different countries.Students will show their partners and peers their bills and coins from their heritage countries. They may tell or ask about the stories behind the graphics on bills and coins. This enhances cultural exchange and helps them to become global citizens in the future. 

Moreover, through learning shapes, areas and volumes, math 8 or 9 students can design and create their own playground at school. They will learn how to minimize the surface area as in unit per cost and maximize the volumes for a maximum capacity for students to play.  From this project, students will come to realize the importance of safety and maximization of capacity so that everyone can share the equipment. This can also use as a project for calculus classes as well.

Cake Recipe

Here are the three cake recipes I found online...

1. Fluffy Plain Chiffon Cake

Ingredients
Amount
In grams
Egg White
4 large
30*4=120g
Sugar
70g
70g
Egg Yolks
4 large
18*4=72g
Vegetable/Olive oil
40ml
37.76g
Water
70ml
70g
Vanilla extract
1 tsp
4.2g
White Flour
75g
75g
https://washoku.guide/recipe/1051046

I've highlighted all the main ingredients in this recipe.Clearly, the ratio between egg white, egg yolks, sugar,water, oil and flour is 120: 72:70:70:38:75, which are a bit different. However, it is interesting that if we look at egg yolk, sugar, water and white flour only, the ratio between them is nearly the same,1:1:1:1. 

2.Chocolate Mousse Cake

Ingredients
Amount
In grams
Unsalted Butter
½ pound
226.8g
Chocolate
8 ounces
200g
Egg Yolks
8 large
18*8=144g
Egg White
4 large
30*4=120g
Granulated Sugar
¾ cup
150g
http://www.foodnetwork.com/recipes/chocolate-mousse-cake-recipe.html

From this mousse cake recipe, the ratio between the main ingredients is 227:200:144:120:150,which each ingredient does not have an equal weight.

3.Blackout Cake



Ingredients
Amount
In grams
Unsalted Butter
140g
140 g
Vegetable Oil
100ml
94.4 g
Large Eggs
2
100 g
Butter Milk
140g
140 g
Coffee
100ml
100 g
Light Muscovado Sugar
250g
250 g
Plain Flour
250g
250 g
Cocoa Powder
50g
50 g
Vanilla Extract
1 teaspoon
4.2 g
Baking Powder
2 teaspoon
10 g
Bicarbonate of soda
1 teaspoon
7 g

From this blackout cake recipe, obviously the sugar and flour has double of the ratio than the oil and the eggs have. The ingredients in this recipe also don't have the same weight.

From the above three recipe, I do not think the main ingredients in all cakes are about the same weight. However, this might be true for plain chiffon cake. The ratio of most ingredients in that recipe are nearly 1 to 1. 









Sunday, November 20, 2016

Reflect on Hewitt‘s Article

Hewitt Arbitrary & Necessary Part 1 introduces the ideas of arbitrary and necessary math knowledge. Hewitt defines labels, symbols, names and conventions as arbitrary knowledge. He also defines necessary as things that students can work out for themselves and know to be correct.

Usually in a lesson, introducing of new symbols, terminologies and conventions would be arbitrary. These parts although requires only memorization, it is also very important for the implementation of the later content, as the later necessary knowledge are built based on referring back to these arbitrary knowledge.

When introducing laws or formulas, these are the knowledge that I think is necessary. Therefore, it is always encouraging to let students find out the formula and patterns on their own. As what Hewitt says in his article, not all students have the awareness of be able to work the formula out by themselves. This is when teachers should step in and provide some scaffolding and problems in the sequence so that students will be able to see the pattern more easily. For example, when teaching exponential law of multiplication and divisions, starting the class by recalling transformation between the repetition form and exponential form of exponents; gradually leading to solving for multiplication between exponential terms by looking at their repetition forms. By observing the answer obtained from repetition forms, most students will be able to find out the patterns at the powers. Similarly, we would do the same to find out the division law for exponents as well. By using scaffolding to teach the laws of various topics, students will think they come up with their own laws, and they will be more likely to remember it then if they just received that message. Some students would think they are smart enough to come up with the same thing that mathematicians did before. Their sense of accomplishment will strengthen their self-efficacy in doing math. This will be helpful for students to come up with more laws and to explore their ways of solving problems through doing problems.


Overall, when planning a lesson, it is always good to introduce the arbitrary knowledge first. When students are used to the terms that teachers are talking about, scaffolding through a series of prepared problems should be introduced to lead students finding the patterns/laws that meant to be introduced in the lesson. Students are the people who are doing math in the classroom, therefore teaching through scaffolding instead of giving out the formulas/laws, will not just help them to develop their sense of self-efficacy in doing math, it will also help to develop their ability in developing questions and proficiency in finding patterns.

Monday, November 14, 2016

Things that surprised me during my short practicum…

Things that surprised me during my short practicum…


-New technologies are implemented to the classrooms
 [Projecting on the whiteboard. Sensor will sense what you write on the whiteboard and add your writing onto the original PowerPoint.]

-Class management was tougher that I thought for apprenticeship classes

-Be more specific about rounding on numbers
 For university students, getting the right answer is good enough. However, for high school students who are just learning sig. figs and decimals, rounding to the right decimal places is important as part of their curriculum.

-Instead of teaching how and when to use formulas, explaining where the formulas come from and what does the formula mean means a lot to high school students.

-Daily specials were really good at the cafeteria


Monday, October 24, 2016

Campbell's Soup Can Problem

Given the size of the actual Campbell’s Soup can (of normal size) and the height of the bike in the photo, what are the dimensions of the volunteer fire department’s water tank? What is its volume? Does it hold enough water to put out an average house fire? Let height of actual Campbell’s Soup can be h, and its radius be r. Let bike’s height be b.  
With the estimation from the photo, the diameter of water tank is about 2.5 times more than the bike’s height. Therefore, the diameter of water tank is about 2.5b; and the radius is about 2.5b/2=1.25b. 
Since Campbell’s actual soup can has a radius of r, 1.25b/r will give a ratio between the water tank and the actual soup can.

We can use this ratio to figure out other dimensions of the water tank from its actual size can. 

The height of the actual can is h; therefore, using the ratio we’ve obtained above, the height for the water tank is h*1.25b/r. Since the can is a cylinder shape, using cylinder’s volume formula: base times height, the volume of the water tank is π(1.25b)^2×(h×1.25×b)/r 

If we bring in numbers at this step, we will be able to find out the capacity of the water tank. 

Let radius of actual can be 0.035m, height of the bike be 1.10m; and height of actual can be 0.16m. 

Then the radius of the water tank is 1.25b=1.25*1.1=1.375m; its height will be (0.16×1.25×1.1)/0.035=6.29m 

Volume of Water will be: 
 π(1.25×1.1)^2×(0.16×1.25×1.1)/0.035=37.33m^3 
Since 1m^3=1000L, 37.33m^3=37330L 

An average house fire requires 1500L water per min to fight. 
Therefore, 37330/1500=24.89 min 
The cross lay hoses can gush water at 360L per minute. 1500/360=4.17 

The water tank can help to fight an average house fire for about 24.89 minutes and at least four hoses are required in order to put off the fire.

Monday, October 17, 2016

Pro-D Schedule

BC Association of IB World Schools   -    Pro-D Roundtables    -   October 21st, 2016.

Wednesday, October 5, 2016

Letters from Little Red and Tinker Bell

A Letter from a Grumpy Student

Hi Ms. Huang,

My name is Little Red. I was one of your Math 10 students from Grimm's High. To be honest, I really don't like you because you always picked me to answer questions during class. I had no interest and I did not know how to answer the questions. I felt very embarrassed every time you called my name and I knew we both knew I would not have the answer for your question. Thinking back now, Math was my worst and least favorite subject because of your teaching style. I hope you've changed now and learnt to respect students by not always picking the worst student in the class to answer your questions.

Sincerely,
Little Red

------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A Letter from a Happy Student

Hi Ms. Huang,

I am Tinker Bell! How is it going? I can't wait to tell you I just finished my master degree in Math and I've got a job at Math Department in Grimm's School Board. Thank you for inspiring my interest in math when I was in Grimm's high. I remembered you always came up with different interesting math art projects. I really enjoyed them. It was then I realized math is not just about doing algebra, it is also about art and creativity. Math is in our every day life! Now I am working at the school board, I will try to engage my thinking in math inquiry to the current curriculum. I wish to inspire more students to love math and enjoy mathematics.

Love,
Tinker Bell

Monday, October 3, 2016

Group Problem

In the division problem below, each letter represents a different one digit number. Determine the number represented by each letter.



Two Influential Teachers

When I was five,I had one of the most negative experience towards teachers, a math teacher in kindergarten. At that time, I had little interest or innate ability towards math. Math to me was a subject of numbers, randomly arranged. For example, I never understood why 5 came after 4. I can still recall the hard time I had during those years. To make matters worse, I had a single experience that was the last straw on the camel's back. I was doing homework one night, but was stuck on one math problems from 6 pm to 10 pm. theatrically, after a strong wind, the homework paper was blown from the 4th story to the roads. My father stated it is too late at night to retrieve it, and as expected, the paper was gone the next morning. I was anxious and fearful by the time I arrived at kindergarten and when the teacher asked why I had no homework to submit, I explained the story. To my worst memory, she sneered scornfully and said no more. This event had permanently shaped my view towards education. I learnt to respect a student at all times. As a teacher, one must support and allow time for the students to adapt in their own way. A teacher's unintentional distrust or disinterest can have lasting effect on a child and decimate a child's trust and eagerness to learn. In addition, it can create a lasting trauma psychologically towards teachers and learning in general.


Luckily, I met a pivotal teacher when I was in grade 4 on the subject of math. He reignited my interest in math and fundamentally influenced my pursuit in mathematics and statistics and as a future math teacher today. Surprisingly, his most memorable teaching technique is to lead us to the playground for outdoor activities at the end of his classes. During that time, he would give incorporate math questions into the play relating to the concepts taught that day. Giving the context of the heavy Chinese elementary course load, outdoor time is like blowing air into vacuum. I felt the enjoyment of study, and for the first time, accepting math as an interesting subject. I started to develop interest and would seek the help of this teacher after hours on math questions. Looking back, this was a startling transition from fearing math to seeking a math teacher to discuss math problems willingly. This marked a significant psychological transition. The teacher not only taught math, but taught the skills to explore new knowledge, thinking and dissecting a problem. This experience allowed me to learn the fact that learning should happen in a "stress-controlled" environment. Minimizing a student's stress increases the effectiveness of learning.

Reflect on Marcus Kantz Presentation

Our presentation was on Marcus Kantz’s Polygons of Equal Areas. Our group was fully prepared during the weekend with a colorful poster and a PowerPoint. However, during the presentation, the link we had in the PowerPoint could not be opened because the laptop wasn’t connected with the internet. We found that such technical issue was due to our lack of experience in teaching and could have been fixed if we arrived earlier before the class. This teaching experience also informs us that we should always have something ready to talk about in case of any technical problems.

As for the content for our presentation, our group spent few hours searching and thinking about application of Marcs Kantz’s polygons of equal areas. However, very limited information was found. Therefore, we focused our activity on developing the students’ interest in creating polygons by asking the class to draw and make their own polygons. By doing this, not only would students be more familiar with the shapes of polygons, they’d also be able to develop a sense in understanding the relationship between the length and number of sides in in relation to the area.

Saturday, October 1, 2016

Word Puzzles

First Puzzle:  
  The fiddler and his wife,
  The piper and his mother,
  Ate three half-cakes, three whole cakes,
  And three quarters of another.


  With all the cakes, how many cakes will each person get? At first when I looked at this riddle, I was confused on how to divide three of everything equally into 4 sectors for each of the people mentioned in the riddle.  Although 3 is not divisible by 4, multiples of 3, such as 12, might be divisible by 4. Therefore, I added up all portions of the cakes mentioned in the riddle, (3*1/2) + 3*1 + (3* ¼) = 21/4. In this case, 21/4/4=21/16, therefore, each person will have 1 and 5/16 cakes.        
I tried to see if there were other answers, and I noticed that if the fiddler’s wife and piper’s mother are a same person, then we would have only three people in the riddle. Thus, each person would have one of the three half cakes, one of three whole cakes and one of three quarters cakes. That is, each person would have ½ +1+ ¼ = 1¾ cakes.


Second Puzzle:
       Brothers and sisters
       Have I none,
       But that man's father
       Is my father's son

The relationships in this riddle are complicated, who is "that man" and what is his relationship with "I"?  I try to make sense of it by applying the relationships in my own family tree. Imaging if “that man” is my little brother, then “that man’s father” is also my father; however, it won’t make sense in the next phrase because my father cannot be also “my father’s son”. This implies that I may want to lower the seniority of “that man” in the family by one more generation. Therefore, I assume “that man” is my little brother’s son, or my niece.  “That man’s father” is then my little brother. My little brother is also “my father’s son”. Therefore, my niece will be “that man”. However, according to the riddle, I should not have any siblings, which implies “that man” is actually myself. In other words, then “that man” and “I” are a same person.               


Both riddles require the thinking technique to see two people as one person. This method connects two sets of relationships that don’t seem to interfere together.  This thinking method is essential when doing extended ratio word problems in Grade 8 and 9 Math.

Monday, September 26, 2016

The Chessboard Puzzle

As soon as I looked at the puzzle, I realized it would be very tedious and hard to count the sum of squares according to their sizes. Usually, when I encounter into a problem like this, I would break down the question or turn it into a simpler problem, and look for a pattern.

Instead of 8*8chessboard, I started out with 1*1 chessboard. And I found one square only.
For the 2*2 chessboard, I found 4 1*1 squares and 1 of 2*2 square.
For the 3*3 chessboard, I found 9 of 1*1 squares, 4 of 2*2 and 1 of 3*3 square.

I began to see a pattern that for each unit increment in the side of the chessboard, the number of total squares increased by (side length)^2. However, this is just a guess, let us verify by the next chessboard.

For the 4*4 chessboard, I found 16 of 1*1, 9 of 2*2, 4 of 3*3 and 1 of 4*4 square.

I found that the total number of squares is just the sum of square of all possible integer lengths that can be fit into the chessboard.
Therefore, we could find the number of squares in 8*8 chessboard inductively by listing:
Sum of square in 8*8 chessboard:8^2+7^2+6^2+5^2+4^2+3^2+2^2+1^2=204

For a Grade 8 or 9 student, it might be hard for them to realize, and start the question by looking for patterns in smaller chessboards. However, it is a good time to introduce them this inductive thinking, so they can apply this method in other problems in the future. We can integrate the question by asking the students what is the sum of squares in an n*n chessboard. Or even bring the question into a three dimensional context, asking the students how many cubes of all sizes are there in an 8*8*8 Cube?



Tuesday, September 20, 2016

TPI Survey Reflect


My TPI result has a mean value of 34.2 with a standard deviation of 4.56. I think the result is reliable, and it reflects on my teaching persona. I see motivation and building confidence in student as important parts in my teaching curriculum. Thus, having a high score on Nurture would make sense. Being able to read what student's mind and seeing what possible confusions they might have is also crucial in teaching. Not only this, being able to transfer and apply what textbook says to real life situation can make learning meaningful and productive. With these in mind, my intention for transmission, apprenticeship and nurture is 11 and higher which lays a solid foundation for having scores over my test mean value.

However, I am lack of knowledge in Social Reform. This can be seen by my intention score from Social Reform column. I see little connection in mathematics and society. I hope to learn more and see how social reform can contribute to the balance of teaching persona. 

Sunday, September 18, 2016

Math Puzzle





The puzzle contains two sets of numbers, and each of which has different solutions. For the first set of numbers shown above, I’ve found one way of filling in the blanks. Whereas, I found three ways to fill in the blanks for the second set of numbers. However, the solution of “?” is the same,189, for all three answers.
I started out the question by observing the first set of numbers. The largest given numbers go up to 378 and 288, and we only have 1 to 9 to fill in the space. Clearly, we are not looking at addition or subtraction from 1 to 9. Thus, the numbers given are more likely to be the products of the solutions. If we are given with products, then the three spaces in rows and columns must be the factors of the givens. However, there are many ways of breaking down the factors, and I started out by throwing in random numbers. I randomly put in “4” as shown in the picture below.



This is not doable. Although 4 is a factor of 24, it is not a factor for 21. This restriction implies there must be a relationship between the rows and columns.
I used an assimilation to help myself to understand the puzzle better. I see the puzzle like a coordinate plane. And each blank is like a point depends on its x (or row) and a y (or column) coordinates. Therefore, there is a clear relationship between the row and column coordinates. The blank, or the point, should be the common factor of its related row and column numbers.
After sorting out the relationship between the numbers, I began to fill in the puzzle. The first number I filled in was 9 at the most bottom right corner. The reason is, 9 is not a common factor of any other pairs of coordinate points on the puzzle, other than 288 and 378. If we look at the column of 288(288=9*32), we realize that the two blanks left should have a product of 32. There are many combinations of factors for 32. 1*32=32; 2*16=32; and 4*8=32; Out of the three pairs, only the last pair whose factors are within the range of 1 to 9. And the question now is how to distribute 4 and 8 in the two spaces when both numbers can be factors of their row coordinates.
We might be able to figure out the arrangement of 4 and 8 by looking at the other two columns' restrictions. However, the simplest method is to try both ways by hand. I plot out two possibilities with one case when 4 is on top of 8 and another case when 8 is on top of 4. The latter case with 4 below 8 does not work because of the restriction on the column of 21. The explanation is that, since 40=4*10, the rest of blanks on the row of “40” should be either 2 or 5, (10=2*5). However, neither of 2 or 5 is a factor of 21. Thus, having 4 below 8 case should be considered no more. And using the same logic to fill out the rest of the puzzle should be fairly easy.

For the second set of given numbers, I found three set of answers, and all three has the same product or the “?” column. I started out this one by looking at the factors of 28, as this is the smallest number within the givens, thus might contain the least pairs of factors. 28=1*28; 28=2*14; 28=4*7; Only the last pair of factors are within the range of 1 to 9. Since the factor of 4 is 2 and 2, which is redundant, this left us only the choice of having 1, 4, 7 to fill in the first row.
There are 6 ways to fill in the three numbers, it would be tedious and boring for a grade 8 to try all of them. We again will need to eliminate the possibilities first. I started with 7 because 7 is a prime and it is less likely to be a factor for a random number than 4.  I found that 7 can be placed in the first row's last column because 7 cannot be a factor of 40, nor 48. And I list out all possibilities of arranging 1 and 4 in the first two columns using the same logic I have in the previous paragraphs.

I will give this question to my Grade 8 students, as factors, LCM, GCF are part of the grade 8 math curriculum. I will show my class this question in the beginning of the chapter, when most kids do not know or do not recall about the factor contents (from Grade 7). Then tell them they might be able to do the question when we finish the chapter, just to give them a little motivation and curiosity about learning the content.

Tuesday, September 13, 2016

Reading Response:Relational Understanding & Instrumental Understanding

After reading Skemp’s article, I agree with Skemp’s idea that relational understanding is essential in learning and should be introduced more often to learners. I think learning the subject relationally is the best way to transform the short term memory of knowledge into long term memorization, and it will keep the student questioning and investigating into the topic further. 

Moreover, through my past experience with students, I have found that instrumental understanding is no less important than that of relational. This is especially true for novice in learning a new subject. When the students have no understanding of a new subject area, it is useful to have them start familiarizing with the material by learning the technical skills first. After some time of practice, when the students feel more comfortable with the subject material, it would be more effective to introduce the relational concepts at this time, for their better understanding of the new subject. Sometimes, even better, students can work out the relational understanding from some time of technical practices. This way, like what Manjul Bhargava says in his video, when you derive the method yourself, you will never forget.

Of course, as the Skemp’s article has mentioned, there are students that cannot wait to dig into the relational understanding before practice. I like their passion in knowing the theory behind the subject. However, the students who have succeed in understanding the relational theory may still have some questions solved incorrectly. It is not uncommon that students often are overwhelmed with the pride that comes from making understanding of the subject with their own minds. Thus, making careless mistakes. Therefore, in such case, precision should follow closely after relational understanding.

In conclusion, students will maximize their benefit when learning both instrumentally and relationally. It is student’s choice to have either instrumental understanding or relational understanding first. Either way, restoring the balance between the understandings is also essential.