The puzzle contains two sets of numbers, and each of which
has different solutions. For the first set of numbers shown above, I’ve found
one way of filling in the blanks. Whereas, I found three ways to fill in the
blanks for the second set of numbers. However, the solution of “?” is the same,189, for all three answers.
I started out the question by observing the first set of
numbers. The largest given numbers go up to 378 and 288, and we only have 1 to 9 to
fill in the space. Clearly, we are not looking at addition or subtraction from
1 to 9. Thus, the numbers given are more likely to be the products of the
solutions. If we are given with products, then the three spaces in rows and
columns must be the factors of the givens. However, there are many ways of breaking
down the factors, and I started out by throwing in random numbers. I randomly
put in “4” as shown in the picture below.
This is not doable.
Although 4 is a factor of 24, it is not a factor for 21. This restriction implies there must be a
relationship between the rows and columns.
I used an assimilation to help myself to understand the
puzzle better. I see the puzzle like a coordinate plane. And each blank is like
a point depends on its x (or row) and a y (or column) coordinates. Therefore,
there is a clear relationship between the row and column coordinates. The blank,
or the point, should be the common factor of its related row and column
numbers.
After sorting out the relationship between the numbers, I
began to fill in the puzzle. The first number I filled in was 9 at the most
bottom right corner. The reason is, 9 is not a common factor of any other pairs
of coordinate points on the puzzle, other than 288 and 378. If we look at the
column of 288(288=9*32), we realize that the two blanks left should have a
product of 32. There are many combinations of factors for 32. 1*32=32; 2*16=32;
and 4*8=32; Out of the three pairs, only the last pair whose factors are within
the range of 1 to 9. And the question now is how to distribute 4 and 8 in the
two spaces when both numbers can be factors of their row coordinates.
We might be able to figure out the arrangement of 4 and 8 by looking at the other two columns' restrictions. However, the simplest method is to try both ways by hand. I plot out
two possibilities with one case when 4 is on top of 8 and another case when 8
is on top of 4. The latter case with 4 below 8 does not work because of the
restriction on the column of 21. The explanation is that, since 40=4*10, the
rest of blanks on the row of “40” should be either 2 or 5, (10=2*5). However,
neither of 2 or 5 is a factor of 21. Thus, having 4 below 8 case should be
considered no more. And using the same logic to fill out the rest of the puzzle
should be fairly easy.
For the second set of given numbers, I found three set of
answers, and all three has the same product or the “?” column. I started out
this one by looking at the factors of 28, as this is the smallest number within
the givens, thus might contain the least pairs of factors. 28=1*28; 28=2*14;
28=4*7; Only the last pair of factors are within the range of 1 to 9. Since the
factor of 4 is 2 and 2, which is redundant, this left us only the choice of
having 1, 4, 7 to fill in the first row.
There are 6 ways to fill in the three numbers, it would be
tedious and boring for a grade 8 to try all of them. We again will need to
eliminate the possibilities first. I started with 7 because 7 is a prime and it
is less likely to be a factor for a random number than 4. I found that 7 can be placed in the first
row's last column because 7 cannot be a factor of 40, nor 48. And I list out all
possibilities of arranging 1 and 4 in the first two columns using the same
logic I have in the previous paragraphs.
I will give this question to my Grade 8 students, as
factors, LCM, GCF are part of the grade 8 math curriculum. I will show my class this question in the beginning of the chapter, when most kids do not
know or do not recall about the factor contents (from Grade 7). Then tell them
they might be able to do the question when we finish the chapter, just to give
them a little motivation and curiosity about learning the content.